DISCLAIMER: The use of masculine/feminine pronouns and assignment of gender roles is not intended to preclude a reversal of gender roles. It is, however, intended to offend those who think that the Y chromosome is the root of all evil. Nyah.
The Symbols:
The green check marks those items which are not so bad, but have been used so many times that it takes a really strong story to lift them out of the slush pile. They will not destroy an otherwise well-written story, and some of the classics employ these elements (and employ them well). | |
The yellow check marks those items which were mildly interesting the first time around, but simply provoke a response along the lines of "been there, done that" on the re-runs. Only a truly bizarre twist on these ideas can give them new life. | |
The green cross marks those items which are baloney, but are tolerable for the sake of dramatic effect as long as the events of the story do not depend on them. | |
The yellow cross marks those items which are lame, and support the plot in some way, but can be saved if there is a supporting justification. For instance, having a robot bleed oil when it gets shot is pretty lame; having a hydraulically-powered robot leak hydraulic fluid when shot is creditable. | |
The red cross marks those items which are irredeemably stupid and cannot be taken seriously without traipsing off into fantasy land. | |
The Starfleet logo marks those items for which Star Trek has been a notable offender. | |
The piggy marks those items that are unconscionably sexist. | |
The swastika marks those items that show racial, ethnic, or religious bigotry. |